📚 Learning Guide
Epistemological and Ontological Positions
hard

A researcher is conducting a study to understand how people perceive mental health issues in different cultural contexts. They decide to use thematic analysis to interpret qualitative data from interviews. Which epistemological and ontological positions should the researcher consider to effectively frame their analysis?

Master this concept with our detailed explanation and step-by-step learning approach

Learning Path
Learning Path

Question & Answer
1
Understand Question
2
Review Options
3
Learn Explanation
4
Explore Topic

Choose the Best Answer

A

A realist ontology with a positivist epistemology, assuming that there is one objective truth about mental health.

B

A constructivist ontology with an interpretivist epistemology, recognizing that perceptions of mental health are shaped by cultural contexts.

C

An essentialist ontology with a normative epistemology, focusing on universal truths applicable to all cultures.

D

A relativist ontology with a critical epistemology, seeking to challenge dominant narratives without acknowledging the role of cultural context.

Understanding the Answer

Let's break down why this is correct

Answer

The researcher should adopt a constructivist ontology, accepting that mental‑health meanings vary across cultures and that reality is socially built rather than fixed. Epistemologically, an interpretivist stance fits best, as it values the participants’ subjective experiences and the researcher’s interpretive role. By acknowledging that knowledge is co‑constructed, the researcher can use thematic analysis to uncover culturally specific meanings and how people actively give meaning to mental health. For example, a participant in a collectivist society might describe depression as a “family burden,” while someone from an individualistic context might frame it as a personal weakness; both perspectives are equally valid within this epistemological and ontological framework.

Detailed Explanation

A constructivist ontology says reality is built by people, not a single fixed truth. Other options are incorrect because The idea here is that there is one objective truth about mental health and that truth can be measured exactly; This option says there is a single universal truth about mental health that applies everywhere.

Key Concepts

Epistemology
Ontology
Thematic Analysis
Topic

Epistemological and Ontological Positions

Difficulty

hard level question

Cognitive Level

understand

Ready to Master More Topics?

Join thousands of students using Seekh's interactive learning platform to excel in their studies with personalized practice and detailed explanations.